evry ones comment on kamala surayya(kamal das)
Topic started by raj (@ 195.229.32.160) on Tue Sep 18 04:05:45 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
Is kamala surayya talented writer or is it all publicity jimmicks
Responses:
- From: Siby (@ 203.199.79.165)
on: Tue Sep 18 04:30:33
It's not kamal das but Kamala Das.
You can start a conversation in the English Literary section.
BTW, what is jimmicks ?
- From: anu (@ 203.115.106.41)
on: Thu Sep 20 13:43:39
she's an eccentric writer
- From: mandoose (@ cache-blr.ernet.in)
on: Fri Oct 5 01:51:23
She WAS a very good writer.. but "urava vattipoyi"
mandoose
- From: Shine (@ nc1.emirates.net.ae)
on: Fri Oct 5 05:22:18
urava vattiyathalla vattayippoyathaa
- From: lalu (@ 204.124.82.48)
on: Fri Oct 5 05:46:57
she has connections with osama bin laden
- From: lalu (@ 204.124.82.48)
on: Fri Oct 5 05:47:18
she has connections with osama bin laden
- From: raj (@ 195.229.32.160)
on: Tue Oct 9 08:47:48
sibby ,
by the word jimmick what I meant was some sort of publicity stunt
- From: rooparaj (@ netcache.qualitynet.net)
on: Sat Oct 13 19:22:53
Dear raj
the word is 'gimmick'not 'j'.Kamala Das seems to be going through what could be a difficult phase in a writer's life.though it does not seem justifiable,is still her own personal life,its only that she seems to enjoy publicly making these seemingly foolish comments.She is still a good writer,one who dared to lay bare her heart and soul thru her work!Hope her condition is a temporary one and she comes out of it producng yet another masterpiece(yes guys and girls ,she does write good works of prose and poetry,not 'trash'like everyone would like to believe!
bye
Rooparaj
- From: chindu (@ nalanda.ker.nic.in)
on: Tue Feb 5 02:28:16
she is a tremendous personality...i do like her truthfulness to herself...she's a free bird..let her fly in her sky...please don't disturb her..
- From: d.murali manohar (@ )
on: Thu Jan 2 04:38:36
a poet who has talent no doubt at all. however she has every right to convert to any religion she wants to. i mention this because there is no much controversy about her. i have written a book on her poetry entitled "kamala das: treatment of love in her poetry" by me (d.murali manohar). if any body wants to buy please write to: dept. of english, university of hyderabad, hyderabad-500 046 with cheque/m.o/ d.d for rs.180/-.
- From: d.murali manohar (@ 202.141.142.20)
on: Thu Jan 2 04:39:56
a poet who has talent no doubt at all. however she has every right to convert to any religion she wants to. i mention this because there is no much controversy about her. i have written a book on her poetry entitled "kamala das: treatment of love in her poetry" by me (d.murali manohar). if any body wants to buy please write to: dept. of english, university of hyderabad, hyderabad-500 046 with cheque/m.o/ d.d for rs.180/-.
- From: shafi (@ dc3.emirates.net.ae)
on: Sun Jul 6 07:13:05
Some of you call Kamala Surayya as an eccentric writer because she dared to embrace a religion which you cannot tolerate.Once I too was a BRAHMAN-but now I feel the warmth of Islam-Learn it from the Quran and experience the change in your attitude and life.
Wish you all the best.
- From: shafi (@ ac9.emirates.net.ae)
on: Sun Jul 6 07:13:28 EDT 2003
Some of you call Kamala Surayya as an eccentric writer because she dared to embrace a religion which you cannot tolerate.Once I too was a BRAHMAN-but now I feel the warmth of Islam-Learn it from the Quran and experience the change in your attitude and life.
Wish you all the best.
- From: Chokker (@ 213.42.2.8)
on: Sun Jul 6 11:16:37 EDT 2003
Okay then.. shafi, u too are an eccentric writer :)
- From: stnly (@ 210-210-64-110.lan.sify.net)
on: Wed Aug 13 08:51:13
kamala surayya got meaning in her life after her conversion to islam ,plz all non believer realize now before its too late the great religion called islam.As u all know islam is the worlds fastest growing religion,why? the answer is with people like k surayya.Wake up all non believers before its too late..
- From: rajeshrs_tvm (@ 202.88.239.106)
on: Wed Aug 13 09:58:54 EDT 2003
it's anyone's right to convert to any religion.
but the way the writer had done that is not worth of her calibre.
suddenly overnight posing in a praying posture wearing a purdah and the 'kadichaal pottaatha'muslim phrases she uttered, all seemed
like publicity gimmick only.
also these writers should only be read ,not worth of following their characters..
this includes
kaviathri ..sugatha kumari
balachandran chullikadu..(another gimmickery of converting to budhism)
- From: bindhu (@ )
on: Thu Oct 23 08:59:54
I LOVE KAMALA DAS BECAUSE HER WRITINGS ARE SIMPLE TO UNDERSTAND. SHE IS A GOOD WRITER.
- From: shaj (@ cache3-2.jed.isu.net.sa)
on: Wed Jun 2 15:53:46
i love her writins and want to see her and want to experience her wast mind affection
- From: Anil (@ cache10-4.ruh.isu.net.sa)
on: Mon Jun 7 02:25:07 EDT 2004
She embraced islam for cheap publicity
- From: bindi (@ )
on: Thu Aug 26 12:13:44
no indian woman writer can stand beside her writing!
Tell your friend about this topic
Want to post a response?
Back to the Forum