Topic started by 4 THE PEOPLE (@ 202.88.245.107) on Mon May 3 09:59:32 EDT 2004.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
Hey Got a TOPIC 2 Discuss.I would like to ask U GUYS about the main casting of YUVA & AAYITHA EZHUTHU.
Both have the same storyline,music,director etc etc So lets see the MAIN CAST.
Aayitha Ezhuthu
SURYA
MADHAVAN
VIVEK OBEROI
RANI MUKHERJEE
ESHA DEOL
KAREENA KAPOOR
Yuva
AJAY DEVGAN
ABHSHEK BACHAN
SIDDHARTH
MEERA JASMINE
ESHA DEOL
TRISHA
My Interpretations R (Marks out of 10 FOR EACH ACTOR)
SURYA & AJAY DEVGAN has the same points. Both has somewhat
the same features, to be precise, MATURED FEATURES.Ajay might
have an edge over Surya due to his experience and 2 national awards.
But Surya takes back beacuse of his immense popularity in his state &
his range is slightly better than Ajay.So AJAY - 8 , SURYA - 8.
MADHAVAN is better in all cases comparing to ABHISHEK.Maddy has
already acted in Mani's 2 movies,better actor & range and popularity
is much much better.But 4 ABHISHEK,His plus point is,if YUVA is
a hit or a flop,He will be noticed after this movie.But one thing common
is both R not having a good time in BOX OFFICE at present.
So MADHAVAN - 8 , ABHISHEK - 5.
Like Maddy's case,VIVEK is much much better than SIDDHARTH.Originally
the role was 4 Shaam,but Mani opted 4 a younger actor.But I think it was a
bad choice.He is neither popular(who wanted to be if U R acting in a Mani
Movie.) nor a good actor.Vivek is better in all ways U can think abt an actor.
U can see the differences in each person's respective scenes in the
trailers.VIVEK looked confident but SIDDHARTH looked dumb.SO
VIVEK - 8.5 , SIDDHARTH - 2.
RANI scores over MEERA because MEERA is not as popular as RANI in
their own industy (But Meera is popular in MALAYALAM).RANI is her
peak time of her career,while MEERA is having 2-3 flops.But both are
equally good actresses.So RANI - 7 , MEERA - 5.
ESHA v/s ESHA.No Competetion.But I heard that the Tamil role was
going 4 JYOTHIKA.Was it True?????But YUVA virtually scores over
here since ESHA is a newcomer in Tamil.
Now to the Underdogs.I think they don't have a great role to play in
this movie due the huge cast & storyline.But a MANI RATHNAM
FILM is always a MANI RATHNAM FILM and they can't afford to
loose it.So they signed for cameo roles.But KAREENA,even though
she never had a hit in her career,she still has a better popularity
comparing to TRISHA.I don't think TRISHA is noticed 4 her acting
in any of her movies.Only as a glamorous item.So KAREENA is
having a better position.So KAREENA - 5 , TRISHA - 3.(4 their respective
roles)
BOTTOM LINE
So YUVA has 33.5 pts out of 50 pts while AAYITHA EZHUTHU has
23 pts out of 50.So YUVA has a better casting in my view.
Now lets see UR VIEWS.BUT ONE MORE QUESTION.If Both "YUVA"
& "AAYITHA EZHUTHU" comes at Ur town same time,which one
would U Prefer?
Tell your friend about this topic