Why the Comedy actor Vivek is always criticising Indian Tradition and our Hinduism in his films?
Topic started by Ram (@ solar.zapsurf.com.sg) on Sun Aug 26 21:55:14 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: stg (@ 12.151.162.88)
on: Sat Feb 2 04:39:08
Most superstitions were time bound and probably has no relevance now. Placebo effect does not mean its a panacea or that superstitions must be followed even now. They may work for fever or headache. You would sue a doctor if he injects you just distilled water when you hand is broken or if you have gangrene in your leg or u had a heart attack. No harm in following superstitions, the problem comes only when people are dogmatic and carry things too far, like not accepting sutures made of animal gut when ur stomach has already been opened and things like that.
Vivek has a lot of sense than we think and most importantly has the guts to call a spade a spade. The only point here is that he has got every RIGHT to criticise all those anachronistic, anti deluvian nonsense.
- From: Raj (@ )
on: Mon Mar 25 18:45:14
irrespective of our debates, these are the facts..
His way is bit different from the traditional comedy way ! And it is enjoyable.
He is humerous.. and follows american way of critizising even the president..
Atleast with his jokes, some movies are getting watchable.
As one of you pointed out.. he can also make jokes which are indegenious and not immitating any one and make people think also.
- From: SHITKICKER_KICKER (@ 203.124.235.137)
on: Tue Mar 26 07:14:12
Mr.SHITKICKER,
You only an idiot.You are a psycho also,that's clear from the nick you have selected for you.
If you couldn't enjoy vivek's comedy then there's something wrong with you.Go to Mr.Mathrubootham,he's a good psychologist:):).
You as**hole just try to understand the jokes he's cracking.I think you lack understanding power.
- From: Maniam (@ lunar-gw.zapsurf.com.sg)
on: Tue Mar 26 09:41:08
Hey,don't scold SHITKICKER. He is too religous and never give out the "Mooda Nambikai". Let him be and against each other in religion matters.
- From: someone (@ 202.95.84.164)
on: Tue Mar 26 20:56:52
relax guyz... a lot of times commedy is based on mere facts.... sometimes, when things r put in a harsh way, pple refuse to listen.... so when u try to make a joke out of somethin to make pple realize their mistakes, it works.... so itz a kind of revolution dat vivek is workin on (i think!)
- From: Harry Potter (@ cache3.simpur.net)
on: Fri Mar 29 10:34:39
Dear Friends,
Do not blame Vivek. His talent is to make every one of us to laugh. He is succeeding in that.
Hinduism is such a Great religion that it does not threaten the people(unlike other religions)that if you talk agianst God you will be punished.It is the religin for free thinkers.
That is the reason Hindus are able to enjoy even jokes on Hindu gods or the tradition.
I can explain this with one example.
In "Minnale", vivek's comedy about the belief of
the lorry driver that a lemon is to protect the vehicle. Every one enjoyed that scene. But if you think deep, when we (Hindus) buy a new vehicle we
take that to a temple and do pooja.
So Reality (the lemon or pooja really do not save the vehicle) but the belief (on God) saves you.
That is the reason we can enjoy the scene even though it is a tradtion.
- From: Ram (@ cache59.156ce.scvmaxonline.com.sg)
on: Fri Mar 29 21:46:30
So Vivek is telling the truth.
- From: Bramins_R_Motherfukers (@ 203.199.240.88)
on: Fri Mar 29 23:23:09
The urine drinkiing bramins are products of incest are worse than pigs and peruchalis and are to be eradicated in larger wellbeing of society. That s why elders have advised that when you encounter a snake and a bramin together, ignore the snake and crush the bramin.
- From: Shakthi (@ bangdp-40-204.mantraonline.com)
on: Sat Mar 30 01:11:36
Vivek's timing and wit is excellent.One can find a subtle, sarcasam in his comedy, in all respects, hence he critises not necessarily religions based practises.
Regarding his comments on tradition and religion, if he practises or adopts a softer way of commenting on certain unwanted beliefs, he would avoid hurting ardent believers. This will also be an eye opener it will rather be a benefit to the society.
- From: Bramins_R_Motherfukers (@ 203.199.240.143)
on: Sat Mar 30 01:46:57
The urine drinkiing bramins are products of incest are worse than pigs and peruchalis and are to be eradicated in larger wellbeing of society. That s why elders have advised that when you encounter a snake and a bramin together, ignore the snake and crush the bramin.
Ps- Vivek must focus on the parpana urine drinkers and educate cine goers about the rapist and incestful parpaana pigs .
- From: TalkSenseOnly (@ 203.124.235.134)
on: Sun Apr 7 12:39:19
BRM, Dey Para Badava, don't you dare use this forum to hurt the sentiments of a community. You are probably the greatest MotherF****r in this world.
- From: ravi (@ bb-203-125-136-217.singnet.com.sg)
on: Sun Apr 14 09:24:40
Does anyone know what is the religion professed by Vivek? If he is a non_Hindu then he has no right to condemn Hindus and is probably working for a hidden agenda. If he is a Hindu then he has a right to criticise the religion.
- From: Castologist (@ 203.124.235.137)
on: Mon Apr 15 10:05:54
Vivek is a Hindu only,and his caste is Devar.
- From: G.Ragavan (@ lan-202-144-44-226.maa.sify.net)
on: Thu Apr 18 05:40:37
Nor Devar. It is Thevar. Both are different.
- From: Philip Menon (@ cache59.156ce.scvmaxonline.com.sg)
on: Wed Apr 24 04:56:02
The Hindu religion has so many loop holes and the Hindu people themselves are crticising their religion. Why the hell are you yelling.
Vivek, you are doing a great job.
- From: ravi (@ bb-203-125-138-3.singnet.com.sg)
on: Sun Apr 28 09:49:28
Mr Philip, you are a Christian. So please refrain from passing comments on this Hindu matter.
If you visit any atheist website you will note that all religions have flaws and filth. As far as Vivek is concerned, he doing his bit to reform his relgion. The world will be a better place if everybody cleaned up their own backyards instead of poking their noses into the affairs of others.
- From: ravi (@ bb-203-125-138-3.singnet.com.sg)
on: Sun Apr 28 09:49:37
Mr Philip, you are a Christian. So please refrain from passing comments on this Hindu matter.
If you visit any atheist website you will note that all religions have flaws and filth. As far as Vivek is concerned, he doing his bit to reform his relgion. The world will be a better place if everybody cleaned up their own backyards instead of poking their noses into the affairs of others.
- From: ravi (@ bb-203-125-138-3.singnet.com.sg)
on: Sun Apr 28 09:51:21
Please ignore the secund posting
- From: Sanjiv /Mahendiran (@ )
on: Wed Jun 12 07:26:51
Vivek Please respect the religion
- From: Iyappan (@ lan-202-144-73-10.maa.sify.net)
on: Wed Jun 12 07:51:12
dear Mr Philip!!
>>The Hindu religion has so many loop holes and the Hindu people themselves are crticising their religion. Why the hell are you yelling. <<
Stop talking nonsense like this .. what you know about hindus and hinduism. what loope hole did you found in that .. and did you try get the explanation from any one .. tell me which hindu has criticising it .. do we need to start criticise what ever religion you belong to..?? Respect others .. it was said in what ever religion you belongs to .. if not through your religion and come, join us we will teach you what it is.. Start living useful life
In Hinduism Nothing is done with out any reason either scientifically / logically. try understand it before commenting on any thing more ever it is not a religion as it is the way of living life.
----
By the way vivek's criticism should be taken as comedy than personal.. adhuvumillama Pazutha maram than kalladi padumgira pazamozi will suit for Hinduism.. Do u think hinduism came so far with out any criticism ?? when you are watching movie.. laugh and forget. dont take it to home
--------
Iyappan
- From: Sri (@ 203.197.228.118)
on: Thu Jun 13 05:52:46
Dear Friends,
We wish to introduce ourselves as your new INSURANCE CONSULTANTS. If you think that Insurance is just taking away your hard-earned money without any immediate gain, THINK AGAIN. Most of the Personal Insurance policies now a days come in form of Investment cum Insurance which gives you Attractive 'Return on Investment' with Tax Benefits plus acts as a collateral security for borrowing funds.
We are representing both Life Insurance Corporation Of India (LIC) and ICICI Prudential Life Insurance. We can provide all the services related to your insurance needs, at one point. We can also take care of insurance requirements of corporate clients and assist you in filing your personal income-tax returns.
In brief Life Insurance provides for
1) Protection (to family and your self’s)
2) Aid to thrift (i.e. Encourages thrift (long term saving's made in relatively painless manner)
3) Liquidity: loans can be availed, surrendered after 3 years, and generally accepted as security for a commercial loan.
4) Tax reliefs under section 88, sec 80ccc(pension plans), sec 80D health plans
5) Money when you need it: plans which suits you
6) Provides for your retirement
7) Achieve higher returns on your investments
8) Protection against inflation,
9) Helps you to have at least same kind of lifestyle even after you retirement and to your family in your absence.
Life Insurance does not have to begin when life ends, a ship may sink, a building may burn, but a man must die. A Life Insurance policy is the most beautiful love letter that a mind of man has ever imagined or the hand of man ever written.
Are your working for money or money is working for you Do you know that we can guarantee a life time income to your family if you die and lifetime income to yourself if you live?
Life Insurance cost less if you buy it and more if your don’t, the heaviest burden an old man carrier is an empty purse.
YOU FINISH THE JOB IF YOU LIVE WE FINISH THE JOB IF YOU DIE
Please write to us to for details of the plans or your requirements we will help you to select the plan and to find quantity of insurance required and we would send you the formula and thumb rule.
Please feel free to send this to all your friends, relatives, etc., because It gives knowledge and puts light for their decision.
Looking forward for your valuable call, to serve you.
Thanks for your time.
Yours Sincerely,
Srinivasachar and Prahaladachar.
Email: licforyou@yahoo.com or iciciinsurance@rediffmail.com
- From: pandi (@ bbcache-13.singnet.com.sg)
on: Fri Sep 5 13:22:51
Vivek is doing a nice job,in a land where lorry is the king of Road.
- From: king of king ,men of men (@ delhi-203.200.95-130.vsnl.net.in)
on: Sun Oct 10 05:29:21
i very much agree with shitkicker or whatever .vivek is an idiot who assumes whatever he does is humorous. i pray to god to instill
some sense in him
- From: Raj (@ 203.200.43.195)
on: Sun Oct 17 16:25:09 EDT 2004
Don't we know the in human caste designs of Hinduism ? therefore we all should convertto a new religion and abandon Hinduism. In hinduism, according to vedas.. we can eat any meat including beef. But according to bagavath geetha.. we should not eat non-veg. Therefore Hinduism is confusive, so it should be abandoned.
Vivek should continue this.
- From: RSS (@ 80.240.229.100)
on: Sun Oct 17 23:04:58 EDT 2004
Vivek will soon die. Keep in touch.
- From: Thirumalai (@ 137.164.229.137)
on: Mon Oct 18 13:52:43 EDT 2004
Vivek is just a coward who is too scared to make fun of superstitions in other religions, because the followers of other relgions would bust out with their swords. Disaster is spelled for vivek's career if this continues.
Tell your friend about this topic
Want to post a response?
Back to the Forum