Topic started by Sonu/udit's Pankha (@ fence.dips.org) on Tue Aug 29 02:57:14 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

Who is better??
Who is more versatile???
Who has his own sweet voice???
Who is natural born talented??
Who doesn't copy anyone?????
Who is more popular now-a-days??
Who is going to stay longer in coming year???

Responses:

• Old responses
  
• From: Ajnabi (@ spider-tf034.proxy.aol.com) on: Sat Mar 2 08:37:53
  
  a_big, I think that the reason the line from the Border song brings tears to the eyes is mostly because of Anu Malik's composition and Javed Akhtar's lyrics. I agree with you that Sonu has a lot of versatility in his singing (probably more than most singers), but I still think that he lacks a real sense of feeling.
  
  Max, I agree that Udit is the best...although I don't know if bringing up Filmfare nominations is very convincing (considering how stupid those awards tend to be - I believe the dumbass film Biwi No. 1 was up for a number of nominations!)
  
  Udit Narayan can also adapt his voice to suit a lot of actors...Aamir Khan (Papa Kehte Hain - QSQT), Shah Rukh Khan (Humko Humise Churaalo - Mohabbatein), Akshay Kumar (Dil Ne Yeh Kaha - Dhadkan), Saif Khan (Yeh Gore Gore Gaal - Dil Tera Diwana)...and more.
  
  Sonu Nigam's lifelong goal seems to be to win an award for Best Female Playback Singer!! I think he's going overboard with the falsetto thing...listen to "Oh Mama Mama" from Rehnaa Hai Terre Dil Mein, man he sounds like he's losing it.
  
  
• From: a_big (@ 203.197.119.102) on: Sat Mar 2 23:13:09
  
  HELLO TO BOTH OF U
  
  u wanting to start a quarrel or what!cool it man.
  
  before telling anything else, just let me put a simple request.If u don't like anyone it's OK, but don't insult the talent of that guy by calling bad names. that may be u'r idea of fun,
  but it may hurt other's feelings. So take care.
  
  MR. MAX, u seem to have not read by post carefully. I myself said that Rafisaab is a legend, and how can you compare a teacher to his student!!I just said that sonu has sung them better than any modern day singer could have, and i still hold my view.I see no basis of your retaliation.
  also u r the first person i hav cum across, who has not liked "Mujhse naraaz..". not only i, but every other critic on the net have praised the song and mind u that Sonu was just about 22, when he was singing the song for ANUPAM KHER!so even if he went a bit overboard with his emotions,he can't be blamed.also i don't understand u'r point about refugee. No doubt udit's song was great, but even sonu's songs were very good and praised by all.so what r u trying to prove?(just for u'r information, did u know that udit was the the singer who sang Panchchi nadiyan, and later sonu was called to sing it again, as it was felt his voice would be more suitable for that song)
  
  mr ajnabi
  the song o mama from RHTDM was featured on R. MADHAVAN. if u have seen the film, u must have noticed, that he and his friends were a crazy bunch who acted crazy, and did everything crazy, So, a funky voice was just the thing needed for such a song.
  
  and don't make baseless comments that sonu has
  no feelings in his songs and all that.for u'r cross reference you may refer to the music review of yeh zindagi ka safar from www.indiafm.com,
  and from www.planetbollywood.com, search tera jadoo chal gaya, border,sarfarosh and the recent pyaar kia nahin jaata and tumse achcha kaun hai.
  
  
  finally. No hard feelings. whoever we may like or dislike, we must never create unnecessary tensions between us. the world is already seeing a lot of violence.
  
  
• From: Max (@ spider-wl061.proxy.aol.com) on: Sun Mar 3 01:08:10
  
  Panchi Nadiyan was sung by Sanu, then dubbed by SONU. DON"T TWIST IT!!!
  
  Not a big acomplishment to dub Sanu
  
  
  
  
• From: Max (@ spider-wa044.proxy.aol.com) on: Sun Mar 3 02:31:47
  
  Attention Mr A Big:
  
  I did not say anything about 'Mujhe naraaz...'
  in my previous post. Though I agree he sang it well, I must mention that Udit's 'Ghar Se Nikatle te hi' was the more popular song of that movie.That song was designed for Udit and udit only.
  
  
• From: a_big (@ 203.200.168.177) on: Mon Mar 4 05:03:12
  
  Sorry boss!!
  got confused between movie titles(papa the great or papa kehte hai whatever)
  
  yeah now i remember the name of the movie, which had that stupid looking kishan kumar.well i don't remember any song from that movie, and i don't think the movie deserves to be remembered.
  
  anyway, sorry for the confusion. keep writing. bye.
  
  
• From: Ajnabi (@ spider-wj054.proxy.aol.com) on: Mon Mar 4 07:08:28
  
  a_big, actually you're right about the Rehnaa Hai Terre Dil Mein song...it's more the composer's doing than anything.
  
  I'm not saying that Sonu is the least emotional singer in the world or anything...it was just my personal opinion that he seems less "feeling" oriented and more of a "trying to be modern/stylish" singer...but I can see how one can think differently.
  
  Yeah, no hard feelings :-)
  
  
• From: a_big (@ 203.197.119.102) on: Mon Mar 4 18:48:52
  
  YEAH:-):-):-):-):-):_):-):-):-):-):-):-)
  
  thanks
  
  
• From: a_big (@ 203.200.171.136) on: Fri Mar 8 04:01:48
  
  what happened friends?
  
  
• From: bla bla (@ wwwgate6.motorola.com) on: Fri Mar 8 15:46:01
  
  hey man come on no one is good
  all are ok
  
  best is Mukesh and Rafi
  
  so don't fight both nigam and shanu are worst and sonu nigam is very very bad
  
  
• From: Name (@ spider-wb074.proxy.aol.com) on: Mon Mar 11 07:02:21
  
  bla_bla, why are you still listening to Hindi music if you think that all the singers who are alive are so bad?
  
  
• From: ahmad (@ 202.179.146.6) on: Tue Mar 12 08:09:52
  
  udit is way ahead of nigam without a .0001 % dout
  
  
• From: Ranju (@ spider-wo012.proxy.aol.com) on: Sat Jun 1 21:54:18
  
  I think that Sonu is da best singer in the whole Bollywood industery! :)
  
  
• From: ME (@ spider-wo012.proxy.aol.com) on: Sat Jun 1 21:55:49
  
  {glo}Sonu Rocks{glo}
  
  
• From: E Ajinabi (@ spider-tm071.proxy.aol.com) on: Mon Jun 3 15:40:42
  
  Kids these days have no respect of music
  but have total admiration of noise
  
  If the singer sounds gay or in the middle of an orgasm then they are labled "Great Singers"
  
  Sonu Nigam, KK, Abhijeet, backstreet boys, n-sync
  Julio Iglesias are SOME examples of the former
  
  Britney Spears, Jessica Simpson, Sunidhi Chauhan, are SOME examples of the latter
  
  
• From: nikki (@ host217-39-130-91.in-addr.btopenworld.com) on: Wed Jun 12 16:37:01
  
  east or west...sonu is the best
  
  
• From: big boss (@ 203.90.76.138) on: Sat Jun 22 02:57:28
  
  well i find sonu the best hearing the song sooraj hua maddham from kabhi khushi kabhi gham.
  
  
• From: asad khan (@ 210.56.22.79) on: Tue Jun 25 04:12:35
  
  udit is better
  
  
• From: Raina (@ ool-435043e2.dyn.optonline.net) on: Mon Jul 1 20:22:58
  
  Sonu is aboout a million times better than Udit, and it shows. Notice how dumb Udit sounds in Bole Chudiyaan fron K3G compared to Sonu? All the peeps that answered "Udit" are seriously out of taste.
  
  
• From: Notorious MAX (@ spider-ta061.proxy.aol.com) on: Mon Jul 1 23:10:37
  
  Is Bole Chudiyan a real song?
  
  If you seem to merit such songs as Bole Chudiyan,
  I will certainly ignore your opinions on Udit.
  
  Does the gay factor fit into the song as well?
  In that case Udit is of that lagging also
  
  
• From: r (@ 203.199.213.3) on: Tue Jul 2 08:55:03
  
  pj
  
  
• From: . (@ 203.202.129.251) on: Mon Jul 15 07:01:04
  
  SONU IS BETTER!!!!!!!!!!!111
  
  
• From: . (@ 203.202.129.251) on: Mon Jul 15 07:01:16
  
  SONU IS BETTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  
  
• From: . (@ 203.202.129.251) on: Mon Jul 15 07:02:04
  
  I agree with Raina TOTALLY!!!!!!!!!
  
  
• From: She (@ 203.202.129.251) on: Mon Jul 15 07:04:53
  
  E Ajnabee, while I don't agree that the guys sound gay, I DO agree that the females sound like they are in the middle of an organism, especially Britney Spears!!!!!
  
  
• From: Sudin (@ 203.208.140.130) on: Mon Jul 22 04:46:02
  
  Hey guys! What's up yaar?
  U r quarreling in a small thing.......
  Sonu Nigam cannot be compared with Udit...even Sonu Nigam respects him and considers him the best singer in the industry today......then why r u all guys just quarreling.......
  Udit was the best,is the best and will be the best.......
  
  
• From: ts (@ 203.199.213.5) on: Mon Jul 22 06:20:34
  
  
  SONU AND UDIT ARE GOOD FOR NOTHING.THEY ARE NOTHING COMPARED TO JAYACHANDRAN SONGS.HE IS THE BEST SINGER IN INDIA.
  
  
• From: arslan (@ 217.17.181.3) on: Tue Jul 23 07:34:01
  
  both of them are really good but ,,,,Udit is best.
  everyone knows that A R Rehman is the best musician in indian film industry,,,,and most of times he choose Udit to sing his song as his songs are so hard to sing,,,,,,proves the fact udit is gr8888...dont say a harsh word about udit or i'll killl u stupid ppl.
  
  
• From: Maheen (@ cache-dr10.proxy.aol.com) on: Tue Jul 23 21:35:50
  
  I dont think that we could compare sonu to udit because UDIT IS THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!. i dont say that sonu has bad voice but comparing to udit i like udit better.dont u guyes see that almost all of the songs are getting singed by udit. that means udit is the best in the bollywood film industry. Just for my opinion.
  Bye
  
  
• From: sajumon (@ banjo.cs.iitm.ernet.in) on: Wed Jul 24 09:50:14
  
  
  sonu and Udit are good in their area but JAYACHANDRAN is the best of all.He got talent in singing than all of them.
  
  
• From: Farah (@ cache-rl04.proxy.aol.com) on: Sat Jul 27 20:19:59
  
  whatever u guyes say but i think Kumar Sanu is the most talented in all the film industry well
  i am big fan of Kumar & Udit. They r the Best man.
  this is ma opinion.
  UDIT & kUMAR Onlyyyyyy!!!!!!!!!
  
  
• From: sooraj (@ 203.199.213.5) on: Sun Jul 28 01:06:59
  
  
  Sonu is good udit is good kumar is good JAYACHANDRAN the best.
  
  
• From: Manzar Gul Wazir (@ 203.135.34.144) on: Mon Jul 29 11:53:34
  
  One & Only KUMAR SANU is the best.
  
  
• From: Misguided Soul (@ ) on: Sat Mar 29 13:10:25
  
  Hi guys,
  Actually Udit has fair voice but SONU is the best & ll be he best alwayszzzz.In every Song of Sonu you see classic but in udit's song even i can't see.
  Just SONU is the best thats it.
  
  
• From: hayat (@ 202.63.200.4) on: Sat Apr 12 10:49:25 EDT 2003
  
  gugyug
  
  
• From: Mutton (@ 193.188.97.151) on: Wed Apr 23 16:27:31 EDT 2003
  
  
  KUMAR SANU AND JAYACHANDRAN RULESSSS!!!!!!
  
  
• From: KUMAR SANU is the BEST. (@ ) on: Wed Jul 23 08:06:13
  
  mr (@ 203.89.140.3)
  you change your name (Nayyar, imran khan, daud, Waqas Hanif, Noor, Saeed Ali, Desimusic) and more to come. i don't know what is your name lakin tumhari baaton se yeh pata chalta hai ke you are badwa, gandu, kamina, kuta, gada, randi, dala, harami, and more to come.
  
  please please don't show your felling as a worst fan of the great UDITji.we know Udit is very good and nice singer but please don't say he is better than KUMAR SANU.
  Udit is the best.
  but
  The King of Bollywood KUMAR SANU is the BEST of the BEST.
  The King of Bollywood KUMAR SANU is the BEST of the BEST.
  The King of Bollywood KUMAR SANU is the BEST of the BEST.
  The King of Bollywood KUMAR SANU is the BEST of the BEST.
  The King of Bollywood KUMAR SANU is the BEST of the BEST.
  The King of Bollywood KUMAR SANU is the BEST of the BEST.
  The King of Bollywood KUMAR SANU is the BEST of the BEST.
  KUMAR SANU is father and udit is his son. please listen the song BEPARWAH BAHUT DIN GHOME......CHIRAGH(1997).
  SANU: Beparwah bahut din ghome, khatam karo azaadi, soch raha hoon BETTA ab main kardon tumhari shaadi.
  Udit: mat socho mere PAPA meri, barbadi karne ki, yeh bhi kya koi umer hai PAPA, Shaadi karne ki.
  
  
• From: neelam (@ host-208-60-254-227.mia.bellsouth.net) on: Fri Aug 1 02:55:35 EDT 2003
  
  OMG! I CANT BELIEVE ANYONE WOULD EVEN TRY TO COMPARE SONU N UDIT.......UDIT IS GOOD, NO DOUBT...BUT SONU IS THE ABSOLUTE BEST, WHO ELSE CAN SING A RAFI SONG SO GOOD...ESPECIALLY NOW WHEN ALL THIS WEIRD SHYT IS IN STYLE, SONUS THE BEST AND THATS IT....YALL KNO ITS TRU
  
  

Want to post a response?