Topic started by Bonnie (@ pool-141-151-13-108.phil.east.verizon.net) on Sun Apr 13 09:28:05 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

HEY.....GUYZ AND GALZ..WAT DO U THINK..? ITS AGAIN THE MAMMOOTTY VS MOHANLAL...KINDA COMPETION. ITS GOINA BE A TUF COMPETION!!!!...KILICHUNDAN VS CHRONIC BACHELOR...WHICH ONE DO U THINK WILL BE RAVED BY THE AUDIENCES..I THINK MAMMOKKA AFTER A LONG COMEBACK WILL SHOW THE REAL TREAT ON THE SCREEN RATHER THAN LALETTAN WHO HAD FLOPS RECENTLY...Ningal ellarum CHRONIC BACHELORINTE songs keto...ente goday..adipoli annu.. .Athu decide cheyunathu..ningala.. TO HEAR THE SONGS GO THE MAMMOOTTYS FAN SITE www.mammootty.cjb.net WHICH ONE DO U THINK WILL BE A HIT??????......MAMMOOKKAS OR LALETTANS COMMENTZZZZ PLEAZZZZZZ...

Responses:

• Old responses
  
• From: malayalam-film-fan (@ 164.164.86.66) on: Thu Jun 26 07:01:00 EDT 2003
  
  >> and also remember that thandavam has collected 4 crore in first 14 days.
  
  Ayyoo...chettayee.. chirichu chirichu mannu kappi.
  ingane ella thamashakalum koodi ore thread-l thanne adichu vidathe.
  
  
• From: jibi (@ dialup-67.31.39.20.dial1.newyork1.level3.net) on: Thu Jun 26 07:54:08 EDT 2003
  
  all the gorss of onnaman and thandvam wouldn't come close to 4 core .. may be he meant lakhs
  
  
• From: Joseph Isak Scaria (@ 203.200.21.66) on: Thu Jun 26 08:01:05 EDT 2003
  
  Read "Vadakkan veragadha" in MT's Story and not in Bharathans direction. THat was a framing mistake.... :-)
  
  
• From: Joseph Isak Scaria (@ 203.200.21.66) on: Thu Jun 26 08:14:02 EDT 2003
  
  Go thru the below given url for more info on Onnamana collection.
  
  http://www.manoramaonline.com/servlet/ContentServer?pagename=manorama/MalArticle/Malfullstory&cid=1054722618749&c=MalArticle&p=1014383589557&colid=1014383589647&channel=MalMovie
  
  
• From: bryan (@ 202.88.236.206) on: Thu Jun 26 10:57:54 EDT 2003
  
  of the vishu releases ,Chronic bachelor is the no 1 movie...Nothing new could be expected from the movie...But the film is not boring...it has got vey high collections in ernakulam....kilichundan and thilakkam run out of theatres..but CB is still running in Padma theatre...i didnt get ticket for balcony in the 70th day for CB.In trivandrum also CBis in Sreekumar and kilichundan is in SreeVisakh(small theatre).Mammooty is made a controlled performance in the film.Mukesh's comedy is good..How is Mammooty looks so glamourous in his old age?..Keep it up...Better go mammooty..Best of luck for pattalam"...i also saw kilichundan...the picturisation is good...Priyadarshan is making mohanlal a bafoon in the movie....no story..old thara thamasha...very much waste than dilips waste comedy...the songs are some what good...sreenivasan is only person who is ok in the movie...what happened to Mr mohanlal...what happens your acting..Mohanlal reduce your fat...hope for your next movie "balettan"
  
  
• From: bryan (@ 202.88.236.206) on: Thu Jun 26 11:17:05 EDT 2003
  
  Mammooty is the on eperson who has done a variety of roles than mohanlal.....
  Look at the roles in "vadakkan veeragadha and vidheyan"entirely different
  roles in maravathoor kanavu and chronic bachelor different.......
  Roles in Ponthanmada and Amaram entirly different..
  roles in Mrugaya" and "valsalyam" very vey entirely different.....
  "SuryaManasam" and "Dany"..both are dump characters but different..
  Thaniyaavarthanam and kauravar .....what a variety...
  he is the best in achayan role(kottayam kunjachan ,Maravathur kanavu,Sangam)
  best in vadakkan kadhakal(vadakkan veeragadha)
  best in muslim role(1921)...
  best in decision making role(CBI,jagratha,newdelhi)
  he is not flexible....and he cant dance...without dance and flexibily he grabbed 3 national awards simply bcoz of acting...
  he is best inb dialogue presentation(the king)....the longest dialogue movie in malayalam...
  as a valyettan role(valyettan,hitler,Johny walker)....
  Donty forget movies like Vartha,adiyozhukkukal,Purappadu,adimakal udamakal,
  athirathram...superhit movie..
  acted in children s movie also for audience sake(manu uncle)..
  omly malayalm actor ho make waves at tamil film industry...(dalapathi,makkalaadchi,arasiyal,mounam sammatham)
  guest roles(kaiyethum doorathu,narasimham)..
  Mohanlal doent did soo many variety roles...except..vanaprastham,kamaladalam,..
  kireedom and bharatham has same range,....
  kilukkam chithram mazha peyyunnu ..madhalam koottunnu ,and all priyadarsan movie ..except kalapani...
  his highness abdulla...is nice...ofcourse he is a nice actor.....
  Mammooty is fluent in every language......Look at his glamour even in his old age....Jayaram can do roles that priyadarshan give to mohanlal...but Mammooty roles r done by he himself...
  ithinte peril 4 theri kettalum saramilla ...ollathu paranju..
  
  
  
  
  
• From: jibi (@ dialup-67.31.29.11.dial1.newyork1.level3.net) on: Fri Jun 27 01:23:33 EDT 2003
  
  joseph issac sacria
  
  i watched tht movie .. nothing new man . there was different opinions abt onnaman production ..the producer and director on the one side and the distributor on the other side..
  
  with commonsense the truth lies on the distributor its only collected 1.50 cores of gross in 5 months . and it had 3 core cost .. thats is too much , it has nothing to offer for 3 cores ..even boring visuals . the producer and dir said they shoot abt 1.25 lakhs feet films and they changed to 98000 feet .. from wht i heard the dir just did tht film to pay the money he owed with producing couple of movies years back . the producer played with him
  
  
• From: Joseph Isak Scaria (@ 203.200.21.66) on: Fri Jun 27 03:33:58 EDT 2003
  
  My opinion is not based on mammooty or mohanlal or any other actors... All I want say you guys is that it not only mohanlal or Mammooty is the best actors and most the artists in the film industry are very taleneted. Look at Mamukoya or shankaradi or any other actors, they all are very talented and natural, even you cannot feel that the they are acting in celluloid. they are living in the screen. And a after all a film is a team work.
  
  You guys are talking about only mohanlal and Mammooty. Every actor will have good time and bad time in their life as you have in your profession and it is the same with actors too. Its all part of life guys.....
  
  What I was trying to say is that the problem of Malayalam film industry is not because of these actors...especially not because super human roles. its purely lack of good stories.
  
  See so many new faces in actors bench now a days but not even single person whoc can really effect the ausience in screenplay ,directing and lyricists and music directros side...
  
  Only one way you can blame thease actors that they have not groomed new stroy writers and other technicians.. I don't know whethere they will be able to do that.
  
  And final thing I want say you all that don't become too narrow minded.. be open minded and don't even talk about any specific actors or releigion or cast etc.. Think little deep and you all can understnd there is no point in all thease comparison. And all thease arguments are nonsense.
  
  Instead of comaring Mammoty and Mohanlal do some comparison yourself with other succesfull persons and try to grow in your buisiness/profession as much as you can.
  (Mohanlal and mammooty are making nice money in all their films irrespective of hit or flop)
  :-) :-) :-)
  
  Last four days I was in a holiday so I got enough time to talk in this forum..Nice talking to u all. I on duty from tommorow onwards. see u in next holidays
  
  -Bye
  
  
• From: S Raman (@ 203.145.186.2) on: Fri Jun 27 03:47:42 EDT 2003
  
  I fully agree with Joseph
  
  
• From: Dipti unnikrishnan (@ 202.54.13.34) on: Fri Jun 27 03:54:50 EDT 2003
  
  I Partially agree with Joseph...
  But I personally like only Mohanlal movies in malayalam. He is very versatile actor.
  
  FYI He is selected Ram gopl vermas next film too along with Amithabachan.
  
  -Dipti
  3 rd year Degree
  Delhi
  
  
• From: shilpa (@ ppp-219.65.105.68.chn.vsnl.net.in) on: Fri Jun 27 04:29:07 EDT 2003
  
  malayalam films are waste.you stupids are fools.
  
  
• From: bryan (@ 202.88.236.206) on: Sat Jun 28 10:29:00 EDT 2003
  
  Who said malayalam movies are waste....They are the best...ever... There is only two languages who dominated the indian film industry...Malayalam and Bengali.....Is there a sathyajit ray in hindi...hindi movies are really waste except some...hindi audiences are utter waste....Even tamil has got talented persons...like manirathnam,...ilayaraja...ar rahman ...kamal hassan....Shilpa i know that you dont like this...but i,m talking the fact...
  maamukkoya and sankaraadi are good but they are not so good...Joseph scaria...i,m not arguing with you...An actor is one who is capable of doing as much variety of characters in easy way and the audience must like it... the eg you taken is really waste...Tell bout thilakan and nedunudi venu..i agree with you...i had never seen mamukkoya in a christian or hindu character role(may be 1 or 2)...Snakradi ..which film he acted sooo superbly ..So joseph dont simply bla blah....First understand and say something
  Shilpa we are stupid...But what bout you who doesnt have this much knowlege....pen buddhi pinbuddhi...chumma chilaykkathe chumma irunnodi...
  stupid,fool ennokke veetil irikkunnavare vilichal mathi avaru kelkkum...Malayali aayal mathru bhashayoodu sneham venamediiiiiii pulleeee....
  hey good stories are here now also...but nowadays shilpa like people are the audience for malayalam movie......do u think ...why sadananthante samayam flopped(it gives a message to all ..)but also the film failed....gramaphone has a good story line....why it flopped...kasthuriman has a good story line...why it doesnt bcom a super hit than chronic bachelor...Does kalyana raman ,koonan ,kuberan ,meesamadhavan....has got a good story line..?if yes tell me the story sacaria....why it become a hit...bcoz only of comedy.........Comedy is the main factor ...not story line...kettoooda....Mammooty ,mohanl;al ivarokke story yulla kadhakal ishtam mathiri abhinayichu kashtapettittanu ithrayum ethiyathu......kettadaa...pen vanibhakesil jagathy undaayittu poolum jagathykku enthu popularityyaa..eda joseph scaria,,,,Now the audience doesnt like stories...So the director even though it has a good story line comedy athinte akathekku kuthi thirukum ketto monae....
  
  Mammooty is making good profit....But why we bother about that..He is acting its a profession and gets salary... under....stand
  All the film is a team work...Bindu panicker & kpac lalitha are a very good actress....But can you ever forget mammooty ,mohanlal ,premnazir ,satyan ,jayan...
  you must have forgotten adoor bhasi,muthaya,kottarakkara...p.j antony, bcoz they are all side actor who can very well act...
  But the heroes are ever time heroes we can t deny them bcoz of side actors ..kettodaa....
  If i hurt any body plzz sorry...Love you shilpa,,...with luv..Bryan
  
  
• From: thava (@ dup-200-64-191-49.prodigy.net.mx) on: Sat Jun 28 11:08:41 EDT 2003
  
  both useles
  dilip is king
  
  
• From: thava (@ dup-200-64-191-49.prodigy.net.mx) on: Sat Jun 28 11:09:31 EDT 2003
  
  both useles
  dilip is king
  
  
• From: Goverdhan_kaalapani (@ 213.42.2.7) on: Sat Jun 28 13:52:03 EDT 2003
  
  Thava...
  Mamooty acted in KING
  Mohanlal in PRINCE
  Dilip in JOKER
  Any indication of positions? ;-)joke.. dilip is good these days...
  regrds
  
  
• From: Arun (@ 61.1.228.176) on: Sun Jun 29 14:09:43 EDT 2003
  
  Thilakkam only by the publicity of Swargachitra.Kalyanraman- average.sadanante samayam & gramaphone were flops.Dileeps film seems like a cartoon.His comedy is riding bike & car without dress.walking without mundu.comments plzz
  
  
• From: Bonnie (@ pool-151-197-169-56.phil.east.verizon.net) on: Tue Jul 1 02:13:07 EDT 2003
  
  Byan...seems at least u got some new answers to share why mammookka is best!!!..Way to Go Mammookaaa!!!
  www.mammootty.tk
  
  
• From: shani (@ 202.88.234.107) on: Mon Jul 7 07:38:25 EDT 2003
  
  Is there any chance to compare Kilichundan with chronic bachelor. chronic is a super duper mega hit film and kilichundan is just opposite from tht. Both Mammooty and Mohanlal r excellent and talented actors and both of them will shine in their roles suited to them. Dont compare Dilip with them and insult them. He is just a waist and will soon disappear after 2 or 3 films.
  
  
• From: chintz (@ ) on: Fri Aug 1 15:29:11
  
  kilichundan mampayam is a superb movie better than chronic bachelor and other vishu releases.
  
  
  go and see it first before giving all dirty comments about this.
  
  
• From: hiral (@ 206.49.102.4) on: Fri Aug 1 15:32:09 EDT 2003
  
  maybe mohanlal might have not suited well for the role in kilichundan mampayam but u cannot say he is a bad actor. he tries his level best.
  
  but not always do u suceed. so encourage lal for better roles than critisising him.
  
  

Want to post a response?