KAMAL?MAMMOOOTY?MOHANLAL?-> My thoughts

Topic started by SAAGAR (@ dialpool-210-214-17-116.maa.sify.net) on Sat Sep 8 07:34:20 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

TITLE CREDIT TO ANUPB.(@202.9.186.188)
Since i felt i've written a comparitively long post i thought of starting a fresh thread.
Kindly excuse Mr.Anup B.
======

Kamal haasan:

1.Great thinker of Cinema.
2.Has got wide knowledge on all fields of Cinema
3.Personality wise he looks like a north indian at the same time a south indian too.
4.Ability to bring out the best from his co-stars and cast the field's best technicians for his
movie.
5.Non shakeable spirit to be on par with the world cinema.
6.He is a director by himself

As an Actor== no doubt. one of the best actor who can perform any role.

But...
1.He has got some irritating mannerisms which i think ,due to the influence of too much viewing
of hollywood movies.In his 80's movies his hand gestures,scratching forehead,his made up(some times too much)style,
and his voice modulations were irritating.

We can put Kamal as a perfect Actor who do 100% justice to a role.(If he acts as a trumpet player.
He gets trained how to hold a trumpet/If he had 2 speak madrasi styled accent he learns that).
He is an Actor Who acts.But he often can never be natural.

We can feel he is acting when he acts.
Like the death scene of nayagan. The sounds he made and the acting were good.But we know he is acting.
But at the sametime we can never forget his roles in Apoorva Sahodharargal,16 Vayadhinilae,Nayagan,
Indian,Avvai Shanmugi(2 nmae a very few).And I feel he comes natural only if he wears masks.
============================
Mammooty:

I feel like Kamal he is a perfect actor who is ready to sacrifice anything.He is at his best when
it comes to Manly roles.But equally he can do it with ease when it comes to Ponthanmaada or Soorya
manasam kind of roles.Who can do the role he had done in Amaram?KamalaHassan?Mohanlal? NO NO .
He is at his 2 extremes.
Either he can make a perfect manly actor.(I think no one in India can beat him when it comes to
voice modulations) or putting masks (aged characters/Period Characters) .
But..
He lacks creativity in doing comedy scenes.Ditto for Dance numbers.THese are his limitations.

==========

Mohanlal:

Mohanlal can never do justice to roles done by mammooty in movies like
Amaram,Vadakkan Veeragaadha,Aavanaazhi.Also he can never do an Indian,
Avvai Shanmugi,Chaplin(Punnagai Mannan) or a 16 Vayadhinilae.

But i think he has got the greatest ability of being 100% true to natural.
Let it be any roles.HE NEVER OVERACTS.can anyone tell me a single movie in which he overacts?
He may not know how to make use of his voice modulations,but it is like a person at ur
home talking 2 u.Like a family member who is in front of u.
I feel this is a blessing for him which i am sure it is not his trained way of performing.
The way he moves around here and there while he speaks, the way he folds his dhothi while speaking,
his middle class movies made by Sathyan Anthikad are enough to speak of his greatness.
=======
i consider Kamal as a perfect actor,creator and thinker of cinema.
Mammooty as a perfect actor.
Mohanlal as a Natural and blessed actor whom can never be outperformed.









Responses:


  Tell your friend about this topic

Want to post a response?

Post a response:

Name:

E-mail:


Please Reload to see your response


Back to the Forum