Topic started by paul (@ a080-0992.nycm.splitrock.net) on Sun Jan 14 20:09:16 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

I feel Sonu Nigams voice is too immature for our macho heroes in the bollwood film industry. We have two great singers in Udit and Sanu and compared to their greatness Sonu Nigam is a kid. Nowadays because of the popularness of the punjabi music he is getting more songs to sing. He dubbed Sanus songs in Refugee and dubbed UDits songs in 1 2ka 4. Is it right step? What is your comments?

Responses:

• Old responses
  
• From: usman (@ 63.100.210.21) on: Sat Jul 21 07:28:51
  
  well i dont think that comparing someone is not good or fair coz always one person in the specific field is the best so one should have courage to accept it,inspite of one's liking or disliking.i was reading some of the responses and one person remarks rubbishly that "If sonu would have come in Mohd. Rafi's time then Rafi definately would have been in trouble".ofcourse sonu today is ahead of other singers,and has very good voice and higher range but ispite of all these qualities one should think before making such statement about the greatest male playback singer of subcotinent,who is followed by large number of playback singers including sonu.nevertheless today sonu is the best,no doubt about it and one should not hesitate to say this.
  
  
  
• From: sree (@ 61.1.145.143) on: Tue Jul 31 06:27:22
  
  SONU ofcourse is the best,there can be no doubts about it.the dumbo who started this thread should actually be thanked,for it has become the meeting place of SONU's fans.well,comming to the singing part of it,SONU definitely scores over sanu and udith in all aspects,be it the range,voice,or emoting-when it comes to emoting,nobody can beat him.perhaps only unnikrishnan from the south can MATCH(mind u,not beat) him in emoting.i'm yet to come across a girl whose eyes haven't moistened after listening to his deewana.and his control over the voice is just amazing-being a student of music,i can vouch for that.and people who know something about music,will agree that he sings the perfect shruti,an aspect udith and sanu can never boast of!the fact that sonu makes even an average tune sound good is enough to say that he is the best among the three
  
  
• From: KUMAR (@ 203.145.150.222) on: Wed Aug 1 14:27:48
  
  sonu is good no dought but i think udit is a bit better. Udit has a youthful voice and suits on almost everyone. kumar sanu is a piece of SUKHI "TATTI". DRY POTY
  
  
• From: KUMAR (@ 203.145.150.222) on: Wed Aug 1 14:27:54
  
  sonu is good no dought but i think udit is a bit better. Udit has a youthful voice and suits on almost everyone. kumar sanu is a piece of SUKHI "TATTI". DRY POTY
  
  
• From: amit bagul (@ dialpool-210-214-151-129.maa.sify.net) on: Fri Aug 3 07:13:15
  
  I think that paul whoever he is has no knowledge about music. Beacouse SONU NIGAM is the best singer i have ever listend to.
  by the way this is special message to paul
  "dont ever dare to say a word to him or i am gona smash your sucking mouth"
  
  
• From: aaaa (@ a080-1006.nycm.splitrock.net) on: Sun Aug 5 11:04:54
  
  remember Sonus first song? AAti hahin? He sings like a constipated guy
  
  
• From: ali (@ a060-1035.nycm.splitrock.net) on: Tue Aug 7 00:47:06
  
  Kumar Sanu is the king of melody
  
  
• From: sree (@ 202.62.83.34) on: Thu Aug 9 05:39:41
  
  for all u fans of sonu out there,there is a sonu fan cllub at indiatimes.com-we can meet and exchange notes there
  ciao
  sree
  
  
• From: alo (@ a060-1045.nycm.splitrock.net) on: Sun Aug 12 14:55:16
  
  I love KUMAR SANU and UDIT NARAYAN
  I love KUMAR SANU and UDIT NARAYAN
  I love KUMAR SANU and UDIT NARAYAN
  I love KUMAR SANU and UDIT NARAYAN
  I love KUMAR SANU and UDIT NARAYAN
  I love KUMAR SANU and UDIT NARAYAN
  
  
• From: abc (@ fence.dips.org) on: Mon Aug 13 02:17:07
  
  Sonu sings like - A girl is getting an Orgasm --
  ..
  
  
• From: Mahek (@ 212.72.17.30) on: Sun Aug 19 12:09:45
  
  hi I'm a gr8 fan of sonu, if you wanna be friends then mail me at gud_gal@hotmail.com
  
  
• From: Mahek (@ 212.72.17.30) on: Sun Aug 19 12:09:59
  
  hi I'm a gr8 fan of sonu, if you wanna be friends then mail me at gud_gal@hotmail.com
  
  
• From: raja (@ a090-0583.nycm.splitrock.net) on: Mon Aug 20 00:19:12
  
  I like KUMAR SANU . Sonu Nigam is a kid.
  I like KUMAR SANU . Sonu Nigam is a kid.
  
  
• From: krupali mankad (@ dialpool-210-214-53-11.maa.sify.net) on: Thu Aug 30 01:03:37
  
  sonu nigam is best. he is very talented. he is not only a good singer but also good anchor and will be good here too.
  
  
• From: sree (@ 202.62.83.34) on: Thu Aug 30 02:49:42
  
  all u sonu fans out here!we can meet at the sonu fan club in indiatimes.com and exchange notes
  cu
  
  
• From: ali (@ a060-0511.nycm.splitrock.net) on: Mon Sep 3 22:34:54
  
  Kumar Sanu is the best
  
  
• From: Anshul Sharma (@ 202.141.70.24) on: Thu Sep 6 05:52:13
  
  Well, whosoever this paul is,it seems do not have
  any emotions. Or might be that he is unaware of
  the album DEEWANA. I think his ears have been
  unable to distinguish the contrast between JEENA
  HAI TERE LIYE from YAAD and KAISE MAIN KAHOON from
  MAUSAM. Neither, it seems, he has listened to
  DIL DHAPAAK. Can anyone else (including those UDIT
  and SANU) match his versatility??? Really SONU is
  all time best. The way his voice flows up and down is uncomparable. His range can't be matched
  by anyone. Remember DEEWANA DIL from PARDES.
  Hiii! I'm SONU's great fan. If you wanna be friends mail me at anshul1313@rediffmail.com
  
  
• From: abc (@ fence.dips.org) on: Thu Sep 6 06:05:18
  
  PAYRE On Shul Sharma
  If you say Sonu's range is wide -- ok
  But All the Time Best ---
  A bit to much said ---
  Don't you think so.
  Sonu is imitating western singers....
  He is just irritating in his new songs, Singing like a girl is getting an Orgasm is not singing, what you call.
  
  
• From: Anshul Sharma (@ 202.141.64.7) on: Fri Sep 7 04:12:47
  
  pyaari abc,
  If Paul can say that sonu is ZERO as compared to udit and sanu, then I also can call him ALL TIME BEST. And above all, I don't have to give any justification. It's my personal view you may not agree.
  
  
• From: sree (@ 203.200.15.20) on: Sun Sep 9 06:38:07
  
  hi!ther is a fanclub dedicated to sonu @indiatimes.com.how about meeting there?...
  
  
• From: Manzar Gul Wazir (@ 203.135.34.74) on: Tue Sep 11 03:04:44
  
  Sonu Nighm sings like a female.He just sing children songs & when he sings i feel bore and off course evryone.Evry time he try to sing like KUMAR SANU but he can't because KUMAR SANU is versatile singer he knows that how to sing.KUMAR SANU is the KING of BOLLYWOOD.Sonu Nighm is a baby infront of the GREAT KUMAR SANU.Sonu u should learn from KUMAR SANU,Now KUMAR SANU is your USTAD.
  
  
  
  
• From: RATNA (@ 237mwzppp.africaonline.co.tz) on: Sat Sep 22 01:54:13
  
  I LIKE SONU VERY MUCH WOW! HE IS SO CUITE AND CHARMING AND HIS VOICE WONDERFUL
  
  
• From: truth (@ a090-0651.nycm.splitrock.net) on: Sun Sep 23 19:59:46
  
  KUMAR SANU IS THE EVERGREEN singer. He has nothing to prove. Just listen to two brilloant songs of his in the new moview which is coming "yeh Zindagi ka Safar". Kumar Sanu is the king of melody.
  
  Sonu Nogam sings like a female. Udits voice is full of cough. Udit is a chamcha to the music directors so he is getting some songs in return.
  Udit is a sukhi tatti or dry potty.
  
  
• From: FARAH (@ 1cust231.tnt79.chi5.da.uu.net) on: Mon Sep 24 23:41:44
  
  SONU IS THE BEST FROM ALL!!! IN FACT ALL OF THE SINGERS R GOOD ENOUGH!!! BUT SONU IS THE BEST OF THE BEST!!! I WISH HIM THE BEST AND A SUCCESSFUL LIFE AND LUCK WITH HIS CAREER!!!
  SONU IS BEST !!BEST !!BEST!! AND THE BEST OF THE BEST!!!!!!!
  LOVE U SONU!!!!!!!!!!
  
  
• From: nami (@ a060-0460.nycm.splitrock.net) on: Tue Sep 25 00:26:48
  
  Kumar Sanu is better than the BEST.
  Kumar Sanu is better than the BEST.
  Kumar Sanu is better than the BEST.
  Kumar Sanu is better than the BEST.
  
  
• From: amit (@ dialpool-210-214-148-203.maa.sify.net) on: Fri Sep 28 11:43:57
  
  hi i ma amit. you can call me deewana but all i know that he is the best singer whole world has ever heard of he can change his voice in a song several times 9 times in a song as far i have noticed.
  what i am here on this site for is to say that it is complete foolish of saying that he can not sing better. he is THE only singer after great kishor kumar who is in the movies as the hero.
  why?
  because he is the best.
  and for paul
  if you come before my eyes i am gonna smash your dirty mouth you son of witch
  
  
• From: amit (@ 209.191.169.43) on: Fri Sep 28 17:39:37
  
  Sonu Nigam does not change the voice. He cannot control his voice . He does not know whom to copy.
  
  KUMAR SANU ZINDABAD.
  
  
  
• From: jawed kaker (@ 203.135.10.86) on: Sun Oct 7 10:33:40
  
  i think kumar sanu is the best but sonu is also good and i think he too good for pop songs i like his dewaana album but i think kumar sanu comes first and then sonu nigam and about udit he is bore.
  thanks
  
  
• From: vishal (@ 61.0.0.54) on: Mon Oct 8 12:08:01
  
  sonu is best singer after mohd rafi u listen it's voice in deewana ,jann ,yaad and film song like tum bin
  no singer can copete with sonu
  he is best of all singer'ds
  
  
• From: amit (@ a040-0333.nycm.splitrock.net) on: Wed Oct 10 21:07:54
  
  SONU NIGAM sings like a girl. no doubt about that.
  KUMAR SANU IS THE BEST
  KUMAR SANU IS THE BEST
  KUMAR SANU IS THE BEST
  KUMAR SANU IS THE BEST