Topic started by Srinivas Patnaik (@ 210.212.215.252) on Wed Jan 30 11:35:59 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

Don't you think our Indian film awards are doing in justice to Aamir ? Every year he is giving a super duper hits but some one else gets all the awards. Take for example Laagan, Dil Chahta Hai,Gulam,Sarfarosh,Rangeela,Akele hum Akele tum. All these movies are super hits and no doubt he was nominated for the best Actor catagories every year. But Shahruk or Amitabh someone else takes all the awards. Do you think the Media is supporting people like Shahruk,Amitabh,Karan Johar,Yash Chopra i.e all big brands.

Responses:

• From: DJ (@ 208.31.154.100) on: Wed Feb 13 10:44:23
  
  Yes and No....because the other actors have skills too.....and Amir Khans' time will come....Everything happens for a reason.......at least so they say......and i hope so too..
  
  
• From: vibhu (@ dialpool-210-214-145-28.maa.sify.net) on: Thu Feb 14 00:22:09
  
  Except for DCH Amir has not given any Award winning perfomance. Even in Lagaan, his acting was not exceptionally good. All other comparatively unknown actors performed equally well.
  However he may get an award this time due to the popularity of Lagaan.
  Lagaan and DCH are better films than Asoka and K3G.But still Shahrukh is a better actor than Amir.
  
  
• From: Noshina Jaffer (@ 110.208-38-31-0.interbaun.com) on: Mon Jan 20 20:00:23
  
  I personally believe that Shah Rukh khan is an immature actor. In most scenes he overacts, especially in comedy routines. He does emotional scenes well, but once again there is too much crying- so much so that it comes accross fake.
  
  Aamir khan is a superb and a versatile actor and he usually blends well with the script - humour, drama and romance.
  
  I believe Shah Ruhk appeals more to the less thinking folks who do not pay much attention to the details and are content to escape for the couple of hours from their hardships in India. Whereas, Aamir appeals to the more socially conscious, thinking east indians of Canada and United States.
  
  
• From: Noshina Jaffer (@ 110.208-38-31-0.interbaun.com) on: Mon Jan 20 20:01:25
  
  I personally believe that Shah Rukh khan is an immature actor. In most scenes he overacts, especially in comedy routines. He does emotional scenes well, but once again there is too much crying- so much so that it comes accross fake.
  
  Aamir khan is a superb and a versatile actor and he usually blends well with the script - humour, drama and romance.
  
  I believe Shah Ruhk appeals more to the less thinking folks who do not pay much attention to the details and are content to escape for the couple of hours from their hardships in India. Whereas, Aamir appeals to the more socially conscious, thinking east indians of Canada and United States.
  
  
• From: Babak (@ ) on: Sat Dec 6 01:34:22
  
  
  Shah Ruhk is just simply outstanding actor and Mr. Big B he is a heart taking actor gives you pleaseure to watch movies.
  
  
• From: Rinu (@ 61.11.41.93) on: Sat Dec 6 05:14:30 EST 2003
  
  Noushina
  
  Show some films for thinking people before ur comments.Is it the comedy masala 'ishq' or the totally seducing 'Rangeela' or the boring 'Mela' or the films like 'love,love,love or 'baazi'?.Everyone agrees that 'Lagan' was a different film,that does n't mean Amir is a great acter.First of allof all Amir has to give some decent films before proclaiming as a great actor.Except a 'Raja hindustani' he did n't have a super duper hit either.If Shahrukh was a immature acter then there would n't have been so much people who loves him like their family member.
  
  
• From: yassin ahmed (@ ppp-106-33.iam.net.ma) on: Sun Dec 14 15:32:45 EST 2003
  
  salut ca va
  
  
• From: Archana (@ ) on: Sat Jan 24 13:41:08
  
  Most of our awards are popular awards, so these go to the more popular stars. Aamir is a star/actor category. He is a class actor, who appeals to a very selective class, who are thinking audiance. This class of audiance does not run after run-of-the mill movies. They want something different and love to see the actor blend in the character, which Aamir does in every film. So, according to his fans, he should have been given awards for movies starting from QSQT, HUM HAI RAAHI PYAARKE, DIL HAI KE MAANTA NAAHI, AKELE HUM AKELE TUM, RANGEELA, GULAM, 1947 EARTH, SARFAROSH, DCH, as well as LAGAAN. Imagine any other star doing these roles of Raj, Raghoo Jetli, Siddhartha Marathe, Munna, DCP Ajay Rathod, Aakash, and Bhuvan so convincingly and so sensitively. Nobody should diagree on the point of his sincerity and devotion playing these characters. He deserves many more awards. Eighty five percent of American and European press has called him a great actor in the wake of Lagaan, see numerous favourable reviews the movie got by the foreign critiques. No body from India has been given so much credit for their performances outside India, I guess. He is indisputably one of the greatest Indian actors of all times. I am proud of him.
  
  Archana
  
  
• From: Ammar Shahid (@ ) on: Mon Feb 23 05:27:50
  
  aamir is a big hero no doubt and in my opion he dont need awards he is a award in himsef this awards never let him down we love him chaclate hero every herion make big herself with ammir like film dil and qayamat sa qayamat tak there are palnty of actress before they are nothing untill doing film with aamir he is prince thats it
  
  
• From: Ammar Shahid (@ 195.219.145.5) on: Mon Feb 23 05:32:32 EST 2004
  
  aamir is a big hero no doubt and in my opion he dont need awards he is a award in himsef this awards never let him down we love him chaclate hero every herion make big herself with ammir like film dil and qayamat sa qayamat tak there are palnty of actress before they are nothing untill doing film with aamir he is prince thats it
  
  
• From: ss (@ 61.1.246.39) on: Mon Mar 1 04:16:51 EST 2004
  
  Aamir dont go for award function.He believes his work satisfies him .For that he don need any award
  
  
• From: R A (@ postb.hhnt.org.uk) on: Tue Mar 9 11:04:33 EST 2004
  
  I think SRK is one of the best actors in Bollywood at the moment. He is one of the rare breed in India who has made it based on merit and skill rather than based on family connections. He is also a socially consious actor which I like in a mainly political mass propogating industry.
  
  I also believe Aamir Khan is an amazing actor and has not been given his dues by the Indian film awards. However , I believe Aamir Khan does not care about these awards as are they often fixed anyway.
  
  
• From: Gagandeeep (@ cache-loh-aa04.proxy.aol.com) on: Sat Apr 3 11:35:42
  
  This comment is in response to Ra. I totally agree with you and was surprised how much we thought the same. My name is gagandeep and I am from in Pakistan what is your name? Your mame must be beautiful. I am also an ardent fan of aamir and also believe that the awards are fixed. Please write back my tooty fruity
  
  
• From: anita (@ cache-rtc-aa09.proxy.aol.com) on: Sun Oct 10 11:56:40
  
  well my view exactly matches with archana.
  anita
  
  
• From: Indian (@ 128.226.46.37) on: Sun Oct 10 14:40:14 EDT 2004
  
  Well all said and done, SRK is a better actor than myself. I am sure about that! But it remains at that. the fact is that he simply over acts or over react in many scenes. he claims to pump in umpteen energy into his acting and his close associates also substantiate this.. but friends, that just doesnt amount to great acting. acting is all about timing and giving a subtle , close to real-life performance.. and SRK is just not adept at that..
  Bollywood has definitely produced some great movies, but friends, please watch some good regional movies too to guage the real depth of indian cinema. and about acting, I would put KamalHasan, Mohanlal and Anil Kapoor , light years ahead of SRK. that's the truth..only girls like SRK because he cracks girlish jokes and behaves girlishly.
  
  
• From: RG (@ ) on: Thu Oct 28 17:19:05
  
  I think...I mean I believe that Amir is one of the Best...comparing him with Sharooooq is like comparing a artist with worker...when I say worker...I mean Sharooooq is a hard working " actor" ...he works hard to show that he is acting...where as acting somehow comes veryt naturally and gracefully to Amir...
  
  Well to put a point ...AMir is the best...
  
  
• From: S.M.Ahsan.Ibrahim.Kazmi From karachi (@ 63-100-208-33.reverse.newskies.net) on: Sat Oct 30 22:08:26 EDT 2004
  
  I lOve My AAMIR KHAN HE IS THE BEST ACTOR IN THE WORLD..
  
  

Want to post a response?