Memoirs of a geisha

The Hub : English Literature

Hello Guest, Login to post.

Memoirs of a geisha

Topic started by sowmeia on Fri Aug 18 14:57:58 2006. [Full View]

Hi all,

I read memoirs of geisha some time ago. One thing I found intresting about the book was that I learned something about the japanese culture. Cant say if a lot of it applies to the modern world, but I wanted to see if any of you could recommend similar books. Books that provide an insight into a different culture. I cant read "serious" stuff so a fictional book would be nice.

Thank You.

| RSS Feed | Email me when a reply is posted

Responses:

From: Alan on Sun Nov 12 4:41:57 2006. [Full View]

I love the Orient Culture too and have read Memoirs of a geisha.

Other books that you may enjoy are:

The Good Earth- Pearl S Buck
Letter from Peking - Pearl S Buck

Falling leaves return to their roots- Adeline Mah Yen
From: chevy on Mon Nov 13 5:00:59 2006. [Full View]

i wanted to start a thead on this book after i read it .. but then .. i jus wrote in " latest reads" and left. . .book is too good ..

A SYNOPSIS OF THE STORY ..
i read the book ..just after my 12th boards .... so i too was recollecting the "school life" phase that had just concluded in my life.. Speaking of recollections .. this book is perfectly written..
Arthur Golden has recollected the memoirs of a Japanese Geisha. .in the most chronological manner.

An interesting tale portraying the life of a geisha, a life that is atypical, complicated and satiated with formalism. Golden completes seduces the reader with his meticulous and graceful description of a geisha’s life. Aptly titled as “memoirs of a geisha”, this book gives the reader the feeling of having spent hours or days with the most gifted geisha of Japan. The book begins with
“Chiyo” a young and poor child who is mercilessly separated from her family. It describes a child’s perception of deception, perplexity and separation. Then, the cruelty she undergoes whilst toiling to become a geisha and finally the beautiful, elegant and detailed description of the making of the classic heroine, the Kyoto geisha, Sayuri. Today, fiction rarely comes as archetypal as this novel.

it's a bit controversial.. my cousin read it and disapproved it's subject matter..
she's feels..there is no difference between a geisha and a prostitute. .... however in the book .. golden points out the difference between a geisha and slut in the japanese society..
however in our country . if a woman dances, or basically performs in front of men ... to make a living.. she's a slut. but in their society .. geishas are dancers ..in face they hold a great place of respect in the society ..
like mameha in the novel ..

my opinion
My opinion is that. The novel has been narrated is a distinct style. I always thought authors write in their own distinct styles which are influenced by their vicinity and lifestyle but Golden through his novel has proved me wrong. He has shown a feat of cross cultural masquerade. I still can’t believe it that a non-Japanese and that too, a male writer who has produced such an intricate novel.

It is just a story. One doesn’t have to approve it’s contents. Certainly even I never considered the “Geisha” life much dissimilar to that of a prostitute. Yet after reading this immensely believable book, I suppose there is a wee difference. However, this view is from an Indian eye. It may be different to people of other nations. We just can’t set aside this novel on grounds of such petite controversies. This book , for all intents and purposes, doesn’t try to convince the reader to show any difference. It just describes the life of a geisha. I feel any Indian or anyone for that matter, who bets to differ from my opinion, should still keep this book back their shelves. Arthur Golden does deserve an applause.

cheers
chevy
From: chevy on Tue Nov 14 9:05:36 2006. [Full View]

no body else has read it ?
From: Sinthiya on Mon Nov 20 23:00:10 2006. [Full View]

how would you compare the movie to the book?

i haven't read the book.... ....
From: chevy on Wed Nov 22 14:23:17 2006. [Full View]

Sinthiya wrote:

how would you compare the movie to the book?

i haven't read the book.... ....
i havnt seen the movie. . .BUT I dun't think any movie matches the original book.

the book is anyday ,..more entertaining .. .

but this is subjective... people may hav differnt views. .
From: sundararaj on Sat Dec 2 6:19:18 2006. [Full View]

Very interesting info.
From: naren_666 on Mon Aug 4 8:52:19 2008. [Full View]

I read this book a year ago and that was a fantastic book which just gives us a view on japanese culture a few decades ago..! the narration was awesome and perfect.
After reading the book I watched the movie and it was okay. It is so hard to bring the same feeling one gets when reading the book into the screen and hence I feel the movie was good!

| RSS Feed | Email me when a reply is posted

Want to post a response?

(Hello Guest, you need to Login to post a response. Are you a New User? Register first.)

Back to English Literature forum