Christians and the caste system

Topic started by b (@ 202.142.106.175) on Sun Apr 18 15:36:37 EDT 2004.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

Christians and the caste system by Devant Maharaj
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
copy pasted from sword of the truth publications archives
Forward it to a friend
Printer Friendly Page

Devant Maharaj (Trinidad, West Indies)
Christians and the caste system

CASTE is not an Indian word but a derogatory epithet introduced in India by Portuguese missionaries in the 16th century to describe the Hindu society. They assumed that the Brahmins commanded the same authority and power as the Christian clergy did in their own time in Europe. The reality is that the Brahmins in India never commanded the authority and power of the Christian clergy. They controlled neither the economy nor the army, both of which the clergy did in Medieval Europe.

It is a serious mistake to view caste from the European Christian and imperialistic viewpoints. These were hostile to Hindu civilisation and society which they were trying to undermine to serve their own interests. They also lacked the historical perspective necessary to understand it.

To properly study the role of caste, we must look at it from the perspective of Indian history and culture. The Indian word for what is called caste is varna. The clearest definition of varnashrama or duties of different sections of society was given by Sri Krishna in the Bhagvadgita. He says: "caturvarnyam maya srishtam guna-karma vibhagashah." This simply means: "The four varnas (castes) were created by me based on guna (character) and karma (duty)." It was a social order meant to ensure stability and proper functioning of society.

A Brahmin was needed for education and cultivation of scholarship. But he could not exist without the support of Kshatriya, the Vaishya or the Shudra. The Kshatriya was the political leader and warrior. The Vaishya was the trader and Shudra was engaged in productive activities like farming and labour. There is no mention of one caste being superior to another. Every one of them is equally important for the proper functioning of society.

Churches in India and world-wide claim that they do not discriminate on caste lines and they criticise Hindu society for caste discrimination day in and day out. But the fact remains that churches practice discrimination based on caste. This is a paradox of which one must be aware. The Catholic Bishop's Conference of India itself mentions that caste discrimination prevails inside the church. This is the observation of their General Body Meeting held in Varansi, India from March 21 to 28, 1998 and the minutes of the meeting were published in a special issue of Catholic India: Here are some excerpts:

"Christianity is not a caste religion. Church is the people of God and all the people are equal before God. The various churches are also equal. There may be elder sisters and younger sisters among the churches but no superior and inferior. But it is a sad fact that the caste system on which social organisation has been built, has entered into the Church of India.

"The depressed classes of people belonging to the lowest level of the caste hierarchy were known harjans. Today the term Dalits is used to denote them. Literally, the word means the weak, the broken, the oppressed. In the Church today the name 'Dalit Christians' is used to denote Christians of scheduled caste origin. The problem of the Dalit Christians has come to focus today. The Dalit Christians are in fact discriminated against by the government and the churches.

"The rights and privileges given to the Dalits by the government are denied to the Christian Dalits because they were converted to Christianity. It is a pity that in the Church also the Dalit Christians are discriminated against because they are low caste or out castes.

"It seems that the Church has not offered opportunities to the Dalit members to come up educationally and socially. As a result even after hundreds of years of their existence in the church, they remain on the periphery of the community. There are few priests and leaders of the Church from the Dalit section. In the states of Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Orissa, Bihar where majority of the Christians are Dalits and this problem is seriously felt. "

According to the reports 70 per cent of the Tamil Catholics are Dalits. It is reported that out of 14 Bishops in Tamil Nadu only one is a Dalit. The percentage of Tamil priests is only four per cent. There were no significant steps taken by the church until recently to lift the socio-economic condition of the Dalits. Vocation from Dalit Christians have not been encouraged. A Dalit priest's feelings have been expressed in the following words: 'We do understand that vocation is from God, but it boggles our mind why He should choose His priests from non-Dalit only. Is God too casteist? Does He also practise untouchability?'"

In March of this year Communities United to Fight Underdevelopment (CUFU) headed by Arthur Sanderson, a Christian, brought to Trinidad a United States Dalit Dr Birwa to lecture about discrimination of Dalits by Hindus and the caste system. It is unfortunate that Sanderson did not focus on discrimination and the caste system that exists in his own churches.


Responses:


  Tell your friend about this topic

Want to post a response?

Post a response:

Name:

E-mail:


Please Reload to see your response


Back to the Forum